Another “Disproportionate” Israeli Response to Gaza Demonstrators

By | April 23, 2018 | 4 Comments

Israeli children hide in concrete pipe from Gazan rockets

Recently the news was filled with reports of thousands of Gazan “demonstrators,” some armed with gasoline bombs and other weapons, attempting to rush the border with Israel. When Israeli troops responded, about nine Gazans were killed. No Israeli troops were killed, and the “world community” ‒ that is, leftists ‒ condemned Israel for a “disproportionate” response.

The “world community” – which maintained a stony silence while thousands of Gazan missiles rained down on Tel Aviv and a suburb of Jerusalem – now cries bitter tears for the Gazan casualties. But civilian casualties are inevitable in any war, especially when Hamas places missile launchers next to schools, hospitals, and apartment blocks.

The right to life necessarily includes the right to defend it. If I am attacked with deadly force, I have a right to respond with deadly force. If a man kicks in my door and comes at me with a knife, I can shoot him. I am not required to turn my back, run to the kitchen, and try to select a knife of exactly equal length. If I am lucky, the assailant will be dead, and I and my family will be unhurt. Would I deserve to be accused of making a “disproportionate” response? Must I allow the assailant to kill one of my family before I shoot him, to make things “proportionate”?

What the far Left and far Right really mean when they complain about the “disproportionate” Israeli response is that there are too few dead Jews. You will excuse me if I do not share this opinion. Consider this timeline:

Terrorist organization Hamas wins election in Gaza Strip by wide margin, 2005.

Israeli troops withdraw from Gaza Strip and forcibly remove all Jewish residents, 2005

Palestinians destroy Gaza Strip greenhouses that produced vegetables for export. Americans contributed $14 million to buy greenhouses for Gazans, and Israelis left them intact when they withdrew, 2005.

Hamas seizes government offices in Gaza Strip, shooting some political opponents and throwing others off tall buildings, 2007.

After Israeli withdrawal, Hamas launches over 1000 rockets and mortar shells at Israel, most at Sderot, a nearby town of 20,000 inhabitants. The response of the “world community” is to do nothing, 2007.

Israel launches series of air strikes against Hamas headquarters and rocket-launcher sites in Gaza Strip. Civilian casualties are inevitable because the sites are located in populated areas, 2008.

Gazans launch rockets hitting the outskirts of Tel Aviv and – for the first time – the outskirts of Jerusalem. Iron Dome missile defense proves effective but not infallible, 2012.

Civilian casualties in Gaza mount, in part due to Palestinians placing rocket launchers in densely populated areas near schools, hospitals, and mosques, 2012.

Far Left and far Right blame Israel for inflicting more casualties on the Gazans than Israel suffers. But this is due partly to where the Palestinians site their rocket launchers, and partly to the success of Iron Dome missile defense – but not to any restraint on the part of the Gazans, 2012.

After Tel Aviv bus bombing that injures 27, Hamas prays for “black body bags,” while Palestinians (in both Gaza and West Bank) celebrate in streets and hand out candy to children, 2012.

Gazan “demonstrators” rush border with Israel and try to cross. Israeli troops respond, and about nine Gazans are killed. Israel suffers no deaths in this incident, 2018.

“World community” ‒ that is, leftists ‒ condemn Israel for “disproportionate” response, 2018.

They sow the wind and reap the whirlwind. − Hosea 8:7

Shortly after Hamas took over the Gaza Strip, newspapers published a photo of a Hamas member standing on a desk in a government office, wearing a ski mask, carrying an AK-47. The man seemed unaware that desks in government offices are made to sit behind while governing, not to stand on while waving automatic weapons.

This sad situation raises a fundamental question: What determines the fate of nations?

It is obvious that the fate of individuals often is not determined by their merits. We see innocent children stricken by cancer, and good people killed by drunk drivers. We see obnoxious people living long, healthy lives. What happens to individuals, at least in this world, often has little to do with their virtues – or lack of virtues.

But the situation may be quite different when it comes to nations.

In 1933, the world was in the grip of a severe depression. Unemployment was widespread, hunger was common, and social and political unrest were pervasive. On January 30, Germany chose Adolf Hitler as chancellor. On March 4, only a month later, the United States inaugurated Franklin Roosevelt as president. Those choices proved fateful for both nations.

Hitler revived the German economy with a huge buildup of armaments. But he began murdering political opponents, and then precipitated the bloodiest war in history. At the war’s end in 1945, only 12 years after Hitler came to power, Germany was defeated and disgraced. Its cities were flattened, its industry was in ruins, and many millions of its people were dead. It took decades for Germany to regain its place among the nations, though even now it remains considerably reduced in size, power, and prestige.

Roosevelt, less successfully, tried to revive the American economy with social programs. But he overcame political opponents at the ballot box. Then he led the nation to victory over Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. At the war’s end in 1945, America was victorious, honored, and richer and more powerful than before.

Other factors were at work, including size, population, allies, and perhaps luck. Some might add Divine intervention. But the fact remains that by their choices of leaders, Germany and America determined their national fates.

Yes, there were anti-Nazi Germans, and there were pro-Nazi Americans. But there were not enough of them to matter. When Allied bombs caused firestorms in Dresden and Hamburg, the anti-Nazis were incinerated with the Nazis. A nation’s fate is determined by what the majority of the people allow the government to do. The minority, who oppose these policies, share that fate. This may not be fair, but it is reality.

And it is also true that Hamas runs social-welfare programs. So did the Nazis. Hamas gives money to the poor. So did Mafioso John Gotti. Tyrants and crime bosses do some obvious good in order to gain popular approval, but this can never justify the vast amount of harm they do.

When Gazans went to the polls, they chose Hamas by a wide margin. They showed the world that they endorse terrorists who openly call for the destruction of Israel, who sponsor suicide bombers, and who want all the Middle East, like Gaza, to be judenrein − “cleansed” of Jews.

The Palestinians chose a Nazi-like organization that espouses a Nazi-like program. Then why should anyone be surprised when that organization acts like Nazis? Why should anyone be surprised when that organization murders political opponents? Why should anyone be surprised when that organization takes over the schools and enforces its hateful program to indoctrinate the next generation? Why should anyone be surprised when all Jews are expelled, and Christians are severely restricted? That’s what Nazis do.

The Germans at least had the excuse that nothing as awful as the Nazis had existed in modern times. They could fool themselves into believing that Hitler was exaggerating to get votes. They could delude themselves that there would be less violence after the Nazis took power. They could deceive themselves until it was too late, and the Nazis had achieved absolute power.

But what excuse do the Palestinians have? They saw what happened when a nation chose genocidal fanatics to lead it. They saw the horrible suffering that resulted, for the Germans themselves as well as for their victims. They saw German cities flattened and German people − both Nazis and anti-Nazis − killed by the millions. They had the lesson of history, yet they ignored it. If you elect Nazis, you should expect them to act like Nazis – and you should expect your nation to suffer the same fate as Nazis.

The Nazis bombed Rotterdam and Coventry, so they had no right to complain when the Allies bombed Hamburg and Dresden. The Nazis killed civilians, so they had no right to complain when their civilians were killed. The Nazis unleashed a genocidal war, so they had no right to complain when terrible destruction was visited on them. The Nazis caused children to hide in cellars, so they had no right to complain when their own children were forced to hide in cellars.

Those who celebrate bus bombings with candy have no right to complain about civilian casualties. Those who throw political opponents off roofs have no right to complain about lack of self-determination. Those who cause schoolchildren to cower in fear in concrete pipes have no right to complain about anything. Those who pray to their god for body bags deserve to have their prayers answered.

You may call this unfair. You may call it tragic. You may call it “disproportionate.” I call it reaping the whirlwind.

Israeli child is 16 months old; what land did he “steal”?

Contact: dstol@prodigy.net. You are welcome to publish or post these articles, provided that you cite the author and website.
www.stolinsky.com

4 Comments

  • Robroy74 says:

    So what you are saying is that the holocaust, which ended in 1945, entitles Israelis to do whatever they want to Palestinians in 2018. Just how long does this guilt trip last? How long before Israelis have to act like civilized people?

    • David Stolinsky says:

      No, I’m not talking about 1945, I’m talking about 1938. I’m saying that the Evian Conference, which happened in 1938, disqualifies other nations from criticizing Israel for acting to defend itself. Check this out: https://www.ushmm.org/outreach/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007698

      At first Hitler wanted the Jews to leave, “For all I care, on luxury liners.” But with few exceptions, no one would take them in. In 1938 delegates from many nations met in the French resort town of Evian, site of the famous mineral-water spring. The delegates talked. The delegates drank water. The delegates passed water. But they came up with no plan for the refugees. A Nazi newspaper headlined, all too accurately, “Nobody Wants Them.”

      Then came the Holocaust (note upper case), when one-third of all the Jews on Earth were exterminated. Those who refused to take in the Jewish refugees then have no moral right to condemn Israel for existing now. If the U.S. and other nations have accepted the refugees, there would be fewer Jews in Israel now – or possibly no Israel at all. And then there would be no Arab refugees, and no problem in Gaza.

      What would the U.S. do if thousands of angry people with Molotov cocktails and other weapons tried to rush the border? That’s right, the Border Patrol – and troops if necessary – would open fire. In fact, when vehicles try to crash the border, that’s exactly what happens now. That’s what “civilized people” do – they use the minimum force necessary to maintain order, which is a prerequisite for civilization.

      It ill behooves those who refused to take in Jewish refugees then – and who took over the shops, businesses, and homes of Jews who were sent to death camps – to now shed bitter tears for those who elected, by a large margin, terrorists who openly boast of planning to destroy Israel and murder its inhabitants.

      Maybe you know how to reach a compromise with people who want to kill you and take your property – I don’t.

  • CUFI member says:

    After all the Jews were removed, the Arabs could have turned Gaza into a paradise. They could have used the money from the USA and UN to build schools, hospitals and businesses. They could have said, “Look what we can do when you get rid of those awful Jews.” Instead they built rocket launchers and stole the rest of the money to enrich the leaders and leave the people in poverty. They say, “Look what the Jews did to us.” But they did it to themselves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social Widgets powered by AB-WebLog.com.