Reparations for Slavery? Already Paid

By | April 4, 2019 | 6 Comments

Civil War amputations

Whether America should pay reparations for slavery is a subject that intensifies the debate on race. But the question implies something untrue − that no reparations have yet been paid.

The total death toll for both sides in the Civil War was about 618,000. About one-third of a million white men and boys died fighting for the Union. This does not include African American soldiers who died, nor does it include Confederate deaths. That is, this total does not include those who died fighting for their own freedom, or those who died fighting for the Confederacy. It includes only those white men and boys who died fighting for the Union ‒ and thereby ended slavery.

This is not merely theoretical to me. When I was a boy, we lived in the small town of Lisbon, North Dakota. Nearby was the Old Soldiers Home, now the North Dakota Veterans Home. One day my parents took me there to meet Colonel John W. Carroll. He was an ancient man, or so he appeared to me. He had been a teenaged drummer boy in the Union Army, and was now an honorary colonel. I have no idea what he said to me, but I vividly recall his white beard and his dignified demeanor.

Col. John W. Carroll

And I recall my parents emphasizing to me what he had risked his life for ‒ freedom, including my freedom. Though I did not realize it at the time, I was a very lucky child. My rich heritage was taught to me. Today’s children are often not so lucky.

It is said that life is not a sprint but a marathon. This is incorrect. Life is a relay race. Past generations ran their laps as best they could, then handed the baton to us. Are we doing the same? Are we handing the baton to the next generation, as well as Colonel Carroll handed it to me? Or are we fumbling the pass and dropping the baton in the dirt?

Look at total deaths (Union and Confederate) in each of the major battles.

Approximately one in four Union soldiers who served died in the war. The total population of the Union was about 20 million. One-third of a million deaths represented an enormous loss of life. Look at the total battle deaths in all of America’s wars. The Civil War was by far our bloodiest war.

In addition, all serious arm or leg wounds were treated by amputation. Veterans on crutches or with pinned-up sleeves were a common sight on American streets for many decades. In all too many cases, the battlefield surgeons ran out of ether and chloroform, and amputations were done without anesthesia. The mortality rates for amputations ran from 28% to 52%. Conditions in field hospitals were, by modern standards, appalling.

But if all those severed limbs, and all the blood that soaked into the earth from the dead and wounded, do not constitute reparations, nothing ever could. Yet these facts are rarely mentioned when the subject of reparations is raised. Why? Are the dead and wounded unimportant? Or are they merely inconvenient?

Perhaps we have watched too many televised trials and seen famous, high-priced lawyers make mountains of evidence “disappear” to get their prominent clients acquitted.

Perhaps we have watched too many politicians posturing theatrically for the media, while accomplishing nothing even remotely useful for anyone but themselves.

Perhaps we have watched too much TV and seen mousse-haired “talking heads” shamelessly slanting the news, while omitting inconvenient facts.

We may have gained the impression that the truth is not something external that we try to discover, but instead is something we fabricate to suit our own agenda.

We may have gotten the notion that reality is like a buffet, where we can select what we like and ignore what we don’t. We may have gained the impression that, like children, we can bypass the veggies and load up on desserts. No, reality is like a sit-down dinner. We take what we are handed and make the best of it.

Slavery was universal, on all continents, among all peoples. Slavery was unexceptional. What was exceptional was the struggle, often bloody, to abolish slavery. The international slave trade was abolished largely through the efforts of the British Royal Navy. Slavery in America was abolished through the efforts of the Union Army and Navy.

Revealingly, slavery persisted elsewhere. It persisted in Brazil until 1888, and it persists today in some Muslim and African nations, as well as everywhere under the name of human trafficking. But what percent of American university graduates believe that slavery was a uniquely American sin? It would be depressing to discover the answer.

Reparations? They have already been paid. In blood.

Gettysburg 1863

Gettysburg today

Contact: You are welcome to publish or post these articles, provided that you cite the author and website.


  • Accurate history and excellent logic as usual. I have always felt the same and remain surprised this is hardly ever mentioned. I got into an argument several years ago about this, but my opponent left the field disgusted that he had no effective rebuttal, except drifting and complaining about remaining discrimination, income inequality and other unrelated obfuscating issues. I mentioned Obama as president…!

  • I plan to post your excellent article in my website as well. You may be interested on one of my articles on this topic. I had a lot of controversy in the comments about the article that followed.

  • Randy W says:

    You seem like an intelligent person. Why make dumb remarks? It’s not just slavery that people want reparations for. It’s years of segregation, discrimination and lynching. What about all that???

    • David Stolinsky says:

      Reparations for whom, from whom? My family on both sides arrived in the U.S. from Russia and Poland in the early 1900s. How are they responsible for what happened before then? They settled in North Dakota. The Dakota Territory was not organized till the 1860s and had NO history of slavery or discrimination.

      What you are saying is that white people today are responsible for what other white people (not even their ancestors) did in the past. And black people today are owed money for what other black people in the past suffered. This is supremely illogical. Besides, as Jews, my people were not considered “white” until the 1960s, and still are not by neo-Nazis. The KKK had no love for Catholics or Italians, either.

      Who is insisting on separate black dormitories and graduations? It’s “liberals” like you. So I, who had nothing to do with segregation in the past, should pay reparations, because it is demanded by you, who insists on segregation right now. This goes beyond the illogical and reaches the delusional.

      I would be fascinated to discover my uncle’s opinion of all this, but I can’t. He was murdered in the Holocaust because he wasn’t “white.” So who owes whom for what?

      Here’s an idea: Let’s stop digging up the past and try to make the present better, so we can all have a future.

      – “If the present tries to sit in judgment of the past, it will lose the future.” – Winston Churchill

      – “If a nation thinks of its past with contempt, it may well contemplate its future with despair; it perishes through moral suicide.”− J. H. Hertz

      – “The nation which forgets its defenders will be itself forgotten.” − Calvin Coolidge

    • And what about me? I’m Hispanic. My ancestry is mixed, the melting pot of Latin America and settled in the South. Am I to receive or give reparations?

      • David Stolinsky says:

        Miguel, as far as I can tell, both you and I owe reparations to ourselves. Thus the ridiculous descends to the absurd. In logic we were taught to refute an argument by following it to its absurd conclusion: reductio ad absurdum. But this assumes that your opponent recognizes that it is absurd – and cares. I doubt that this is true for the current purveyors of “political correctness.” They couldn’t care less that they are proclaiming absurdities, because their followers also don’t notice or care. Even on my uncle’s farm, they didn’t pile the manure that high.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Social Widgets powered by